SeedSing is filled with music lovers. We can not agree on who is the best band from the States. The Greatest American Band Debate will be a regular feature where we discuss and compare bands started in the good old USA. If you have any suggestions of bands we should debate Contact us seedsing.rdk@gmail.com

During this whole greatest American band debate on the site I have been trying to find a way to put Jimi Hendrix on it some way, any way possible. I thought about doing his first band, the Jimi Hendrix Experience, but Hendrix is the only American in the band. The other 2 guys are English, and if I put them in the conversation, that opens a whole new can of worms. If I were to put them in, I'd have to look at a band like The Band. They are all Canadian, with Levon Helm being the lone exception. So, since the band is 2/3 English, I decided against putting them in.

Then, I looked at doing the same thing with Hendrix that I did with Robert Johnson. I thought that maybe I could put him in based on his tremendous and unparalleled guitar playing,  but when I thought about it more, I decided against this as well. Yes, Hendrix is an all time great musician, but he is not on Robert Johnson's level. I'm sorry, but it is true. Robert Johnson wrote some of the most iconic songs ever, songs that Hendrix himself became famous for covering, and Hendrix is just not on that Robert Johnson level. Robert Johnson is a pioneer, Hendrix just improved on Johnson's invention. While Hendrix is an all timer, he is not Robert Johnson.

But, the other day, while listening to some Hendrix music, I came across my Band of Gypsys record. Now, this was a one off, live record, but it cannot be understated how great this band truly was. This was a time when 3 wonderful musicians came together and put on excellent shows, and released one of the best live albums of all time. This my friends, is how I will finally get Jimi Hendrix in the conversation. Today, I nominate the Band of Gypsys as one of America's greatest rock bands.

Band of Gypsys consisted of three guys, Hendrix on lead guitar and vocals, the incomparable Buddy Miles on drums and vocals and Billy Cox on bass and vocals. These three coming together was a stroke of genius, or "lightening in a bottle", if you will. The three of them are some of the best to play their instruments. We all know how truly exceptional of a guitar player Hendrix was. He is one of, if not the, greatest guitar players ever. He was a genius, he was ahead of his time, and he did things that no one else could ever do on guitar. Billy Cox was a phenomenal bass player, but also a pretty decent singer. His bass on this one record is so, so good. When the band plays their first song, the first thing you hear is one of his bass lines, and it totally gets you in the mood for some great psycadelic rock and roll music. He also does some great backing vocals and lead vocals on the record. Then, we have Buddy Miles. I mean come on, is their a more underrated drummer ever than Buddy Miles? He is to drums what Booker T is to keys. They are both probably the best ever, that no one talks about. Buddy Miles was a tremendous drummer. The give and take that he and Hendrix have on "Machine Gun" is made extra great by Buddy Miles drumming. Miles was also a very, very good singer. His singing on this particular record is the best of all three members. When he sings "Changes", it is one of the best mixes of R&B and rock that I have ever heard. He had a great voice. When the three of them teamed up, they created something so special, it gave me an opportunity to finally put Hendrix in this particular conversation.

Band of Gypsys did a 2 night run, consisting of four shows, that ran from December 31st 1969 to January 1st 1970 at the Fillmore in New York. These four shows produced 6 of the greatest live songs that have ever been put on an album. The record opens with "Who Knows", which has that Billy Cox bass line that I mentioned earlier. Then, Hendrix comes in with his iconic guitar and Miles hammers home the drums. The song is epic, Hendrix does some of his better vocal work and the band sounds incredibly tight. The record then follows that song with my favorite Hendrix song ever, "Machine Gun". I have already talked about the back and forth between Hendrix and Miles, but that song is so much more. The lyrics have a great message. The instrumentation is wonderful. The fact that Hendrix gets his guitar to sound like a machine gun is exceptional. Same goes for Buddy Miles on drums. The solo that Hendrix does on this recording is one of the best solos ever. I love, love, love this song. "Machine Gun" is a must listen. Then we get "Changes". Buddy Miles vocals on this track are great. He belts this song and Hendrix and Cox do some great work on a more upbeat, faster paced song. Hendrix again has a great solo. "Power of Love" has some great back and forth vocals from both Miles and Hendrix, and it is a pretty great psychedelic rock song. Again, Hendrix slays guitar, and I love Buddy miles vocals and drums. Billy Cox's bass is great as well. Another love song follows with, "Message of Love". This song is all Hendrix all the time, and it is great because of that. They close out the record with "We Gotta Live Together". This song showcases all three of them at their absolute best. It is a very great way to close out this very iconic record.

I know the album only has 6 songs, and it may seem like an unfair way, or that I'm shoehorning Hendrix in, but I seriously believe, even though they only did 4 shows and put out one live record, that Band of Gypsys is definitely one of America's greatest rock bands. I mean, Buddy Miles and Hendrix played a lot before they did this four show run. Billy Cox also showed up here and there on earlier Hendrix jam sessions and recordings. The three of them knew each other pretty well, and they used that friendship totally to their benefit when they decided to do these shows together. I love Band of Gypsys, but more importantly, I love Jimi Hendrix. He belongs in this conversation, and if I have to find a backwards way to put him in, I'm glad that Band of Gypsys put out this one record, making them more than eligible.

So yes, I firmly believe that Band of Gypsys is one of America's greatest bands for all the reasons I listed above. They also belong because these three guys are some of the all time greats at their respective instruments. If you like Hendrix, go check out Band of Gypsys, I bet you will love them.

Ty

Ty is the Pop Culture editor for SeedSing and the other host of the X Millennial Man Podcast. If you think Ty is cheating, nominate your own Greatest American Band, write for us. Follow Ty on instagram and twitter.