While out for coffee this morning, a Thundercat song came on while we were driving back. I am a big Thundercat fan. He is a magician, a virtuoso if you will, on the bass.

When the song came on, my buddy Kirk mentioned that he just recently heard of Thundercat. I started to instantly sing his praises. I mentioned how I have seen other people online say that he is like a Transformer on the bass. He is an amazing bassist. I said, after heaping compliments on Thundercat, how I think he is one of the best bassists in the world. I mentioned that the only bassist that I think is better is Victor Wooten. Victor Wooten is truly one of a kind. I saw him live once, and boy oh boy was it amazing. I didn't know much about him when I went to the show, but I left a true convert. I was hooked. I devoured his whole catalog. I have been talking him up ever since. I said all of this to Kirk and my dad, and then Kirk hit me with a doozy. After saying that Wooten was the greatest bassist of all time, and Thundercat was second best, he asked me, what about Les Claypool? I had to sit back and think. I told him that he just shook my whole view on this topic. Les Claypool is also a wizard. He plays the bass like he is from another world. He also plays a bunch of different genres. He is stretchy. He can do some wonderful things on the bass.

Now I am stuck. I don't know who, of these three musicians, is the best at the bass. And I am sure that there are other bassists out there that I am forgetting. I don't listen to jazz or hard rock stuff where bass is a driving force. I don't know some of the underground or not yet discovered artists. Leave me alone. I am going totally based on my listening experience. These are the people I like. These are who I know and can talk a little bit about. If I didn't name your favorite bassist, I'm sorry. But also, get over it.

So, taking these three guys as my base, who is the best? Who plays the best? Who is the best writer of the three? Who has the longest staying power? Who is the most technically proficient? These are a few questions I have been pondering since we first talked about this about two hours ago. So, as far as who plays it best, or who is the most proficient, all three have their own high marks. Victor Wooten is the first person I ever heard play harmonics. He was also going wild at the live show. He was going fret to fret, string to string. He crushed. Thundercat, as previously mentioned, is a transformer. The stuff he does on the bass is second to none. He plays faster than Victor Wooten. He makes it look so easy, but what he is doing is incredibly difficult. He is the first person hip hop artists ask to be on their records. He is truly a virtuoso. As for Les Claypool, I mean, this dude is amazing. He literally shreds on the bass. He makes it sound like a guitar sometimes. He is almost too good at the bass. He has his own circus that he runs, and his band is who everyone wants to watch. He is the best of the best among a group of the best bass players in the US. As far as staying power, they all have a good deal. Thundercat has the hip hop community, as well as his solo stuff. Victor Wooten has a solo career, as well as playing with Bela Fleck and the Flecktones. As for Claypool, he has his circus. He has played with many rock bands. He has his own band. They are all going to be around for a long time. As for writing, Thundercat isn't that great, but his playing hides that. Victor Wooten is more an instrumentalist than a writer. As for Claypool, I almost feel like he is goofing off when he writes songs, and that is a-okay. I also like his goofy lyrics. And his playing is pretty damn dope. So, I am still finding myself stuck. At moments it is easily Thundercat, but then I go back and remember all the stuff I just said about Claypool and Wooten. Wooten's live show is a core memory. But, I haven't seen Thundercat or Claypool in concert as of yet. And they are all incredibly proficient on the bass. If I had to make a pick, if I was somehow forced to, I'd go with Thundercat, but just by a hair. And that may change from moment to moment.

All in all, these three dudes are at the top of their craft. If you haven't heard these guys play, do yourself a favor and start right now. They are all more than worth your time. 

Ty

Ty is the Pop Culture editor for SeedSing and the other host of the X Millennial Man Podcast.

Come and support Ty and the podcast on Patreon.

Follow Ty on instagram.

SeedSing is funded by a group of awesome people. Join them by donating to SeedSing.