SeedSing

View Original

Derrick Rose's Retires as the NBA's Greatest What If Story

Derrick Rose called it a career this morning. He has officially retired from the NBA. You could see this coming after the Grizzlies released him about a week ago. If the place he played his college basketball was not going to keep him on the team, even in an Udonis Haslem type role, the writing was on the wall.

Rose had one of the biggest "what if" careers in the history of the NBA. Rose was a star when he played at Memphis. He was an all American, led the Tigers to their most regular season wins, led them to the title game and their first number one ranking in the polls in 25 years. Sure, there were some issues off the court that were investigated, but that is rampant in college basketball back then, and even now. He parlayed this college success into being selected first overall in the 2008 draft by the Chicago Bulls. This was an easy pick for the Bulls back then. He was the surefire guy. He was the explosive guard that teams coveted. And he was damn good early on in his career. He was the 2009 Rookie of the Year. He put in 16 points per game, 6 assists and 3 rebounds. Not too shabby for a rookie point guard. He made his first all star team in year two. In the 2010-2011 season, Rose went off. The explosiveness that was so coveted came into full focus. Rose averaged well over 20 points, 7 assists and 5 rebounds. He led the Bulls to 60+ wins. They were the number 1 seed. They won their first two playoff matchups. Rose had become everything the Bulls hoped he would be when they took him first overall two years prior. Rose and the Bulls ended up facing the Heat, and they took them down in five games.

Then the injuries happened. Rose got a raise, but tore his ACL in round one of the playoffs against the 76ers. It was bad. Rose missed all of the next season. He came back in 2013-14, only to tear his meniscus in November. He came back the next year, but he still looked a bit off. His bounce and explosiveness was rare and hard to find now. He couldn't get to the spots he used to with ease. It was discovered that he needed another surgery on his right knee. He had torn his meniscus again. He played his last season with the Bulls in 2015-16. He had moments, but he was not the same guy as he was in 08,09 and 2010. He wasn't a feared rim runner anymore. He couldn't beat guys off the dribble. His knees gave out on him.

Rose still managed to stick around long enough to make more highlights post his Bulls playing days. He went to play for the Knicks after the Bulls. He played here and there, not doing too much. He also left the team at one point without telling them. He was going to see his mom. When he came back, he did score 30 in a win over the Celtics. He left after one season in New York due to some differences with the scheme. He went to play for the Cavs in 17-18, joining LeBron James. He hurt his ankle midway through the season, and left the team to decide if he wanted to keep playing. He played here and there occasionally before hurting his ankle again and moving on to Minnesota. He was kind of revitalized, as much as he could at this point. He had one night where he scored 50 and it was awesome to see. It was at this moment when I really respected and was happy that he was one of my favorite modern players in the NBA. He proved how great he could still be when given the chance. He got to play for Tom Thibodeau again, he was teammates again with guys he loved like Taj Gibson and Jimmy Butler and he seemed happy playing again. Rose was a key part to the Timberwolves in their semi return to relevance. After his time in Minnesota he ended up with the Detroit Pistons. I had forgotten about his time there. It was uneventful. He did have seven straight games of scoring 20 points, was a starter again and really embraced the role of a sixth man. After Detroit he went back to New York, reuniting yet again with Tom Thibeodeau. He ended up third in sixth man of the year voting in 2021. He also returned to the playoffs for the first time since 2018. After two seasons in New York, Rose returned to where he played his college ball, signing with the Memphis Grizzlies. He went back to number 23, had a whole video about returning home and got a humongous ovation when he took the court for the first time that season. He sparingly played for a shell of the Memphis Grizzlies. And then he stepped away after being released.

Rose, if he had stayed healthy, could've been an all timer. He was Russell Westbrook before Russell Westbrook. He was such a dominant athlete, but his body betrayed him. It is a real bummer. He showed flashes later in his career, but he was never the same after winning his MVP award. I'm still on the fence about Rose being a hall of fame player. But, those first three years of his NBA career were amazing and extremely memorable. Enjoy retirement Derrick Rose. You were lightning in a bottle until your injuries halted what could have been a great, great career. 

Ty

Ty is the Pop Culture editor for SeedSing, the other host of the X Millennial Man Podcast, and the greatest basketball writer on the internet.

Come and support Ty and the podcast on Patreon.

Follow Ty on instagram.