Ty Watches "Tar" and Has Some Thoughts

Yesterday I watched "Tar". I have heard lots of good things about this movie, a lot of people I read and listen to have talked about it and it is on Peacock, which is a streaming service we happen to subscribe to in my house. I knew I needed a good amount of time so I made sure I got everything done before noon so I could watch it all in one sitting. I prepared myself for a long movie and turned it on. What I witnessed next, I have some thoughts on.

First things first, Cate Blanchett is amazing here. She does a masterful job of playing Lydia Tar, who the movie is based on. She truly embodied this character and made it her own. You cannot take your eyes off Blanchett while she is on screen, which is 99 percent of the movie. The way she portrayed this character, the fact that she learned how to conduct and play piano, among other instruments and how she played the more frightening parts really worked. The hype is real and very, very well deserved.

Outside of Blanchette, I do not understand what I watched. This movie is 2 hours and 40 minutes long and I was pretty much confused the entire time. The movie started with a dark screen followed by credits and someone singing in the background. I thought I messed up the stream. I assumed I started it at the end. I paused it twice to check the time. I was instantly confused. Then, as the movie unfolded, I just could not make heads or tails of what I was watching. There were long, long moments of silence. The quiet scenes may have been put in to provide suspense or tension but it just left me wanting more. I came away annoyed at these long, seemingly never ending silent scenes. Then when Blanchett would have a scene partner it felt like it was a monologue off. Blanchett would go on for minutes and then whoever she was talking to would get their turn. The acting was superb, but after three or four scenes of this it just felt tired. I did like the way they mentioned the pandemic and the stuff with cancel culture was great. But I felt like they were trying to make Lydia Tar, sometimes, feel like a victim. From the research I did after I watched the movie, Tar was not the best person.

I think what frustrated me most with this watch was how little extensive knowledge I have of music and composition. I'm sure the people that love this movie know music much better than I do. They are smarter than I am as well. They would go into great detail talking about the writing process and how hard of a job it is to conduct. I did like the conducting scenes, but there were far too few of them in this movie. But even during those scenes, Blanchett would speak in German and there were no subtitles. I had no idea what she was saying. I could not grasp what she was getting at. And then she would talk to other people involved in music and all of that flew right over my head. I love music. I play guitar. I was in a crummy band before I had kids. But when it comes to classical music I am as green as they come. I think "Tar" was made for people who know all this stuff. I think the people involved made it for people who know how to read music, for people who understand the ins and outs of composing music. I do not have that luxury because I never learned how to read anything more than tablature.

So, while Blanchett is magnetic and an absolute delight to watch on screen, "Tar" was not for me. I guess I am not smart enough or I just don't get it. I was utterly confused for the entire screening. I said to my dog at one point, "I have no idea what is going on man". And he is a dog, who unfortunately cannot talk. I would say, if you want to watch this movie, go in knowing as much as possible about classical music or go in and just enjoy Blanchett's mesmerizing performance. Other than that, it is very frustrating. 

Ty

Ty is the Pop Culture editor for SeedSing and the other host of the X Millennial Man Podcast.

Come and support Ty and the podcast on Patreon.

Follow Ty on instagram and twitter.

SeedSing is funded by a group of awesome people. Join them by donating to SeedSing.