Fans Should Not Have a Say in All Star Voting

Yesterday I was looking at some sports news and the NBA all star reserves were being announced. Let’s discuss.

This is right around the time I start getting back into the NBA, right after all star break. The names were announced, and per usual, there were some surprises and some players that got "snubbed". I never pay much attention to the whole "snub" thing because there's only so many spots on an all star roster and some people are bound to be left off. It's the nature of the beast. And everyone has their opinion on who the biggest "snub" is and who they should replace. It is all being put out on social media immediately just for the clicks. And I don't have a fix for this issue per-say, but I have an idea on how some of this could be avoided in the near future.

My biggest issue with all star stuff, and this goes across multiple professional sports all star rosters, we have to stop letting the fan vote determine who the starters are going to be. I get it, you want the fans to feel involved. This gives them some kind of feeling of being in charge. We get to pick and we think we have some form of power, however slight it may be. The issue I have, fans vote for the same people year after year after year. And the fans that actually vote, they're a mix of small children or fully grown adults stuck in the past. No one who is of sound mind and maturity wastes their time voting for this. In the NBA the all star game is a joke, so why would a legit fan care to even vote? They wouldn't. It makes no sense. But, when I was a little kid, like 11 or 12, I couldn't wait to vote. I wanted to see the players I like play in an all star game. And that was all well and good back in the 90's because I couldn't watch Shawn Kemp, Chris Webber and Gary Payton whenever I wanted. We had no NBA on TNT or League Pass. We got the NBA on ABC, which was usually a Bulls game, and the occasional ESPN game, which were few and far between. So, the sheer fact that I could watch a player I like made me want to vote.

Kids now, like my son for example, are so bummed because Lamelo Ball isn't an all star this year. He loves watching Lamelo play. Me, I don't care about the Hornets and Lamelo plays zero defense, so I have no interest in watching him chuck the ball 25 times a game, if he is even playing. Some kids I coach were upset that Domantas Sabonis and Trae Young are not all stars. Again, these two play zero defense. Young jacks threes and hunts assists and Sabonis can rebound and score, but he is a liability in the post on defense. But I get the joy that they get from watching exciting players, I just don't think excitement lends to being an all star. And kids are dumb with sports stuff like all star rosters. I was dumb when it came to voting as a 12 or 13 year old, so I can relate to my son.

As for the fully grown adults voting, these are the ones voting for Nikola Jokic and Kevin Durant to be all star starters. This is why a guy like Dame Lillard is an all star every year. Steph and LeBron are all timers, but they don't need to waste their time playing in a pointless exhibition game. But the ESPN's and Fox Sports of the world will not have it any other way. These networks are star effers and they have an odd lust to see them play, even though they can watch them whenever they want. Jokic is a zero defensively. Durant is never healthy. Lillard is old and small and maybe the worst defender in the NBA. And, Steph and LeBron, as previously mentioned, don't need this.

I say do away with fan votes. It is a pointless waste of time. Fans will watch no matter what. My son is going to tune in simply because he loves the game of basketball. Others will tune in for their own reasons. But, if they want a legit all star game with legit rosters, go to the coaches with the caveat of no voting for anyone on your team. These people see these players night in and night out. They know the game better than any of us regular fans will ever know the game. Put it in their hands and go from there. Fans will still tune in, and I know that is what is important in this era of sports as entertainment. 

Ty

Ty is the Pop Culture editor for SeedSing, the other host of the X Millennial Man Podcast, and the greatest basketball writer on the internet.

Come and support Ty and the podcast on Patreon.

Follow Ty on instagram.