Ty Answers the "Is Russell Wilson a Hall of Famer" Question
/Russell Wilson announced yesterday that he is retiring from the NFL. This seemed inevitable. He wasn't on a team, no one seemed interested, I don't think he was willing to be a backup and it was time to walk away. At first blush, after he announced his decision, I instantly thought, well he is a hall of fame QB. But, as I have been thinking more and more about it, is Russell Wilson a hall of fame player?
There are certain current QBs playing right now that I think are sure fire hall of fame players. I think Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson are shoe-ins. They kind of helped usher in this new era of QBs. The dual threat QBs that are coveted by certain teams. Allen and Jackson, at least to me, have been the guys who ushered in this new era. Without them maybe we don't get Jalen Hurts or anyone else that plays like him. I believe Patrick Mahomes is a first ballot hall of fame QB. He is a winner, puts up tremendous numbers and led a dynastic team in the Chiefs. I do think, unfortunately, that Aaron Rodgers will be a first ballot hall of fame player. He has the numbers, has a ring, has multiple MVP awards and will most likely be inducted as soon as he is able. The jury is still out on guys like Joe Burrow, Jalen Hurts, Justin Herbert and Matthew Stafford, amongst others.
I have also pondered other players who have been out of the game for a bit now, and are coming up on their possible induction. I don't think Eli Manning is a hall of fame QB, but I bet he gets in. He was the QB of the Giants when they beat those dominant Patriots teams in the mid 2000's. Drew Brees reminds me a ton of Rodgers, with better numbers. Brees is a surefire first ballot hall of fame QB. And then we have guys like Phillip Rivers and Alex Smith. Rivers had tremendous numbers and had a very long and fruitful career. But he never won a ring or an MVP. I don't know if he gets into the hall of fame or not. I do believe he has just as much a case as Eli Manning. Alex Smith is a good story, coming back from his horrific injury. But he doesn't have the numbers, the wins or the allure of the other QBs eligible or already in the hall of fame.
Which brings me to Russell Wilson. Wilson was kind of a surprise star in the NFL for a bit. The Seahawks took him in the later rounds to be Matt Flynn's backup. Flynn proved to be a flash in the pan, and Wilson started almost immediately in Seattle, and they had great success. They won a ring. They went to multiple Super Bowls. They crushed the Broncos when they had what was supposed to be one of the best offenses in the history of football. Wilson was the MVP of the game and looked like his success would continue for a while. They had the second Super Bowl won, until the team decided to throw the ball on the one yard line instead of just handing it to Marshawn Lynch and just letting him fall into the end zone. Wilson has the big game experience of a hall of fame QB, and even a ring. Wilson has the stats too. He put up some big numbers throughout his career. He has multiple 4,000 yard plus passing yards seasons. He has a 40 passing TD season and a 34 passing TD season. He always threw more TDs than interceptions. He had teams in playoff contention almost every season.
Then the trade to Denver happened. He really went downhill during his run in Denver. He couldn't move like he did before. He became a little too obsessed with his own fame. He wanted the limelight more and more it seemed. And that affected his play. He was replaced by, I believe, Jarrett Stidham during his final season in Denver, and made his way to Pittsburgh. He split time with Justin Fields there, due to injury, but he only lasted a season. Then he went to the Giants, and that was a pain to watch. He just wasn't the same. And without getting signed this offseason, he made the right choice to hang the cleats up for good.
In looking at his past stats, and his career as a whole, do I think he should be a hall of famer? No, I don't. He had a great career. He proved tons of doubters wrong. He won a ring. He became famous. But he benefited from having a generational defense with him in Seattle. They had Marshawn Lynch. They had a great o line. Wilson benefited from all of that, as he should have. But, in looking at those Seattle teams he played for, there are a few guys I'd put in the hall of fame before him. I'd put Marshawn Lynch in over anyone else on that team. I'd think much harder about Richard Sherman than I would Russell Wilson when it comes to the hall of fame. Earl Thomas has a better shot in my opinion too. Russell Wilson was a very good, very competent NFL QB. But is he a hall of famer?
I say no.
Ty
Ty is the Pop Culture editor for SeedSing and the other host of the X Millennial Man Podcast.
Come and support Ty and the podcast on Patreon.
Follow Ty on instagram.
SeedSing is funded by a group of awesome people. Join them by donating to SeedSing.